Cognitive abilities, alongside patient emotions, values and experiences are all valid factors that contribute to decision making. More complex decisions will require greater cognitive ability. The UK legislation sets out clear requirements for the presence or absence of capacity. Sensitive exploration of underlying beliefs and attitudes allows the clinical team to adapt to promote capacity. From the MCA asset: Mum was identified not to have capacity to make decisions. For everyday purposes (rather than use in research into capacity itself) toolkits that allow tailoring of the information to an individual decision are preferable. Assessing mental capacity can be a daunting task for both health care professionals and loved ones, particularly as the legal definition of capacity varies between different countries. 31 St John’s Square Address correspondence to: Dr Catherine Pennington, ReMemBr Group, School of Clinical Sciences, University of Bristol, Learning and Research Building, Southmead Hospital, Bristol, UK. When determining capacity to make a specific healthcare decision, the MacCAT-T, SICIATRI or CCTI may be useful. Karlawish JHT, Casarett DJ, James BD, Xie SX, Kim SYH. It has been suggested that in clinical practice, clinicians may equate treatment refusal with lack of capacity and treatment acceptance with competency. High inter-rater reliability, but lower test–retest reliability. Whilst there is a high level of awareness of the UK capacity legislation amongst healthcare professionals and researchers, there is often a lack of understanding of the detailed components that make up capacity and hence more standardised approaches may be helpful. Their design and structure varied, as did the level of reliability and validity data available. Build in questions about cognitive function, concerns about memory, mood and behaviour 3. Therefore, several otherwise useful tools (e.g. There is an increasing awareness of the impact of social and cultural factors in decision making. No test of capacity is applied to the UK voting rights, provided the individual is registered and can express their choice. The person is unable to make the specific decision under consideration. Altered mental capacity can affect not only adults with dementia, but also those with learning difficulties, acquired brain injury or mental health disorders. Papers were screened by title, then abstract. Dementia is a clinical syndrome of deterioration in mental function which interferes with activities of daily living (ADLs). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Geriatrics Society. Others are tailored for people with dementia, learning difficulties, or mental health disorders. They cannot retain information for the time required to make the decision. Many conditions cause a fluctuating cognitive state, for example Lewy body disease and delirium. The following keywords were used as search terms: ‘mental capacity’, ‘informed consent’, ‘capacity assessment’. Biphasic cortical macro- and microstructural changes in autosomal dominant Alzheimer's disease. This does not negate the usefulness of SICIATRI, but it is important to recognise that some tools may require context-specific modification. The UK legislation provides a clear framework for clinicians and researchers when assessing capacity. . ASSESSMENT OF CAPACITY Examples of Impairment Conditions that are associated with Mental Capacity are: Dementia Learning Disabilities, long term affects of brain damage, physical or mental conditions that cause confusion, drowsiness or loss of consciousness, delirium, confusion, symptoms of … If the person has a diagnosis of dementia, this would be true. They are not required to understand more complex details about financial and divorce rights. A learning disability. Internationally, many areas where capacity legislation has been enacted follow a similar model to that of the UK. Wong JG, Clare CH, Holland AJ, Watson PC, Gunn M. Gurrera RJ, Moye J, Karel MJ, Azar AR, Armesto JC. There is a risk of serious harm to those who refuse medical or social care, and professionals who fail to conduct adequate and timely capacity assessments may be guilty of wilful neglect. People with dementia should not be assumed to lack decision-making capacity. This will allow people to be supported to have the highest level of capacity possible and permit those lacking capacity to have their views heard. There is a pressing need for more research in this area but also for more widespread and thorough training for clinicians and researchers. Tools meeting the UK legislative requirements are listed in Table 1. Dedicated instruments exist for people with major mental health disorders, where exploration of potentially abnormal beliefs is required. No gold standard for capacity assessment exists, which hampers the evaluation of different approaches. We compared different methods of capacity assessment, current research and the validity of different methods. London EC1M 4DN, Decisions, Decisions, Decisions: How to assess the mental capacity of people with dementia. Multiple instruments for assessing capacity exist, but none are universally accepted [8]. Mental Capacity: Dealing with Fluctuating Capacity Fluctuating capacity is when a person’s ability to make a specific decision changes frequently or occasionally. Mental Capacity Assessment Dementia Example (Download) Mental Capacity Act 2005 Summary (Download) When carrying out a Mental Capacity Act Assessment, one must consider the 2 stage capacity test. One risk that may undermine the scope of capacity assessments is that they become a memory test—some involve extensive questioning, which draws heavily upon memory. Clinicians should elicit opinions on future care at an early stage, to use in future ‘best interests’ decisions when an individual has lost capacity. Please check for further notifications by email. We reviewed published tools for assessing capacity. People with dementia experience changes to their ability to understand, evaluate and retain information, and may have problems expressing and remembering their decisions. It can also include being bereaved, or shocked after an accident - it needn't be permanent or even medical. Structured interview. They are not able to appreciate the relevance of the information or to use and weigh that information as part of the process of making the decision. In order to have mental capacity, an adult must be able to: Remember the information long enough to make a decision. Such superficial assessments are inadequate and will miss both those lacking capacity, and those who with support (e.g. The Mental Capacity Act code of practice lists examples of when a professional might be ... although Mrs Smith has dementia, her capacity to make a decision should not be questioned ... Before I started the second element of the mental capacity assessment, known as the ‘functional Disagreement about capacity (either between professionals, or between staff and the patient or relatives) should prompt a detailed assessment and open discussion. Whilst these are separate legal entities, their fundamental principles are very similar (Boxes 1 and 2). Undue mnemonic demands should be avoided. Many professionals can assess mental capacity, but none are better placed than an Old Age Psychiatrist with considerable experience and expertise, like Dr … Capacity is particularly relevant in the context of Power of Attorney (PoA), Guardianship, voting, contracts, wills, marriage and criminal responsibility [1–3]. Semi-structured interview using three everyday decision scenarios. Capacity can vary day-to-day, or even hour-to-hour. Developed for people with cognitive decline. Defining and judging mental capacity requires a fine balance between patient autonomy and protection of vulnerable adults. It also avoids confusing adults with cognitive impairment by discussing hypothetical situations—a discussion that is arguably more complex than discussing a real-life, personally relevant decision. Some are more stringent than UK law requires, whilst others are not stringent enough. What is the Test for Mental Capacity The Two Stage Test – Decision Making Capacity. Developed for adults with learning difficulties. Additional relevant publications were identified from selected publications. Aid to Capacity Evaluation) do not meet the UK requirements. 1. Alternatively, it may be that structured assessments (particularly research tools) are too stringent. Limited published data available (no data on reliability available). people with mild cognitive decline, or indeed any older adult), consider PoA for future use. aAlso requires that thought processes be rational. Structured interview, adaptable to different scenarios. Groups such as those with anorexia are particularly challenging to assess, as they are typically high functioning individuals, and their illness is part of their personal identity. Multiple different tools have been developed to aid in capacity assessment. However, for clinicians and researchers looking for training in assessing capacity, or a tool to add to their clinical judgement, the final outcome is often more important than individual sub-scale measures. PART A: CHECKLIST BEFORE CARRYNG OUT FUNCTIONAL MENTAL CAPACITY TEST DIAGNOSTIC TEST These were evaluated against the UK legal requirements. Publications specific to the legal requirements of non-UK jurisdictions were excluded to allow proper cross-referencing to the relevant UK capacity legislation. Most apply the following principles: does the patient understand the disease process and treatment options; do they appreciate that the disease and treatment are relevant to themselves; can they process relevant information and reason out a decision; can they express their choice. Mental Capacity and Competency. MCA assessment was carried out by a Consultant Geriotrician in an A and E department. The greatest challenge is the current lack of a gold standard. One small pilot study of 20 psychiatric patients reported only. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. MacArthur competence assessment tool-clinical research [. avoiding the evening, when confusion may worsen). Peri-operative care for surgical patients, Grants, Fellowships and Research Proposals, Tools for testing decision-making capacity in dementia. This allows decision-specific assessments and simplification of information. This work focuses on methods of assessing capacity meeting the UK legal requirements, and critically appraises current knowledge to identify what may be a gold standard approach towards the assessment of capacity. Information must be provided in an appropriate format, which may mean using simplified language, visual aids or other communication means. Print copy below The content below is reflective of our leaflet. For example, during an assessment the practitioner might remind them that they were recently in hospital and that while there they were referred for an assessment. We evaluated published instruments designed to aid in the assessment of capacity, focussing on those meeting the UK legal requirements. It is therefore vital that we are able to accurately assess a person's ability to make informed choices. A PoA allows an individual to appoint a chosen person(s) to make financial or welfare decisions on their behalf at a future point, usually after the individual has lost capacity. Furthermore, some may require modification for certain groups. It may also vary over time (including over the course of a single day). Copyright © 2020 British Geriatrics Society. High inter-rater reliability. We also consider further disease and culture-specific factors which may influence decision making. These changes all affect whether or not someone has the mental capacity to make their own decisions, but we should not automatically assume that dementia equals a loss of capacity. Capacity assessment tools fulfilling the UK legal requirements. Can be charged to MBS item #717 1. Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) are an amendment to the Mental Capacity Act (2005) to ensure that any care restricting a person's liberty is appropriate and in their best interests. Department of Health Mental Capacity Act 2005 summary. Health and social care professionals must be vigilant to prevent neglect, particularly when individuals with complex neurodegenerative or neuropsychiatric conditions refuse interventions. Individuals scoring highly on neuropsychological tests may lack capacity, whilst others with significant cognitive impairments retain it [22]. Expert opinion and structured assessment can optimise the evaluation of capacity. It seems there is also sometimes little consultation with the person in care or their representative.Many people are confused about what a Mental Capacity Assessment (MCA) actually is – and when it should be used. The article reviews the pros and cons of the different tools available, alongside cultural and neuropsychological aspects of decision making. In some cases, judging capacity is straightforward, whilst in others there may be disagreement between different clinicians, assessment tools or between tool and clinician [25]. Competency to consent to treatment instrument (CCTI) [. Prisons and Probation Ombudsman for England and Wales. Buckles VD, Powlishta KK, Palmer JL et al. Summary of literature review findings (Pubmed; all searches limited to English language publications). 2. Any assessment of capacity must include a: 1. global assessment of the person’s mental state and cognitive function - ideally with an estimate of severity and an assessment of the specific executive and functions of judgment, reasoning and planning which are relevant to decision-making; and 2. a functional assessment of decision-making i.e. This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Moye J, Karel MJ, Azar AR, Gurrera RJ. If a person is later judged to have already lost capacity when they entered into a business or marriage contract, or made a will, these are deemed void. Pilot study of 20 learning disabled adults, 21 with chronic mental health disorder. 1. For those who have already lost capacity, the courts can appoint an appropriate adult to manage decision making. It is good practice to establish how the person with dementia wants to be addressed. Dementia now affects tens of millions of people worldwide. MacArthur competence assessment tool for clinical research (MacCAT-CR). For consent to be valid, the person giving it must have the mental capacity to understand what they are consenting to; it is the same as any other contract or agreement. 1. Conversely, expression of choice is not emphasised in N.American literature, but is a key component of the UK legislation. This may arise from a genuine concern about welfare but might also involve fear of blame or litigation arising from an adverse incident following discharge. ReMemBr Group, School of Clinical Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol Brain Centre, Southmead Hospital, Bristol, UK, Neurology Department, North Bristol Trust, Southmead Hospital, Bristol, UK, Centre for Dementia Prevention, University of Edinburgh, 9A Bioquarter, 9 Little France Road, Edinburgh, UK. Capacity is traditionally evaluated during clinical assessments by psychiatrists and physicians, the reliability of which remains unclear [8]. Whilst the UK legislation presumes capacity to exist until demonstrated otherwise, we must be careful not to abandon the patient to their rights. a wide range of mental capacity assessment instruments is available, but not all fulfil the UK legal requirements. The complexity of capacity assessment means it is unlikely to be successfully reduced simply to a score on a memory test, or tick boxes in a questionnaire. MENTAL CAPACITY ASSESSMENT (MCA) CHECKLIST by Alison Harrison By completing this checklist and answering 'Yes' to all questions (where applicable) you are complying with the Mental Capacity Act 2005. All detected poorer understanding in individuals with dementia. All rights reserved. Changes in care: capacity and decision making. For permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com, This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (. Someone lacking capacity because of a disability or illness such as a learning disability, dementia or a mental health problem would be unable to do one or more of the following four things: Understand information given to them about a particular decision Retain that information long enough to be able Prisons and Probation Ombudsman for England and Wales, Empirical advances in the assessment of the capacity to consent to medical treatment: clinical implications and research needs, Reliability of mental capacity assessments in psychiatric in-patients, Informed content in older medical inpatients: assessment of decision-making capacity, Assessing medical decision making capacity among cancer patients: preliminary clinical experience of using a competency assessment instrument, Structured assessment of mental capacity to make financial decisions in Chinese older persons with mild cognitive impairment and mild Alzheimer disease, Health care decision-making by adults with mental retardation, The development and piloting of a capacity assessment tool, Enhancing medical decision-making evaluations: introduction of normative data for the capacity to consent to treatment instrument, The capacity of people with a ‘mental disability’ to make a health care decision, Cognitive performance predicts treatment decisional abilities in mild to moderate dementia, Validity and reliability of structured interview for competency incompetency assessment testing and ranking inventory, The ability of persons with Alzheimer disease (AD) to make a decision about taking an AD treatment, Assessment of capacity to consent to research among older persons with schizophrenia, Alzheimer disease, or diabetes mellitus, Understanding of informed consent by demented individuals, Decisional capacity for research participation in individuals with mild cognitive impairment, Assessment of decision-making capacity in older adults: an emerging area of practice and research, A new brief instrument for assessing decisional capacity for clinical research, Capacity to consent to treatment: empirical comparison of three instruments in older adults with and without dementia, Consistency of physicians’ legal standard and personal judgments of competency in patients with Alzheimer’s disease, Consistency of physician judgements of capacity to consent Alzheimer’s disease, © The Author(s) 2018. Strengths and weaknesses objective ‘ gold standard ’ cognitive abilities, alongside cultural and disease-specific factors when assessing reasoning the. In dementia: are we battle weary yet of 48 psychiatric and medical patients modification. She leaves residential mental capacity assessment dementia example, expression of choice is not a UK requirement at times... For more widespread and thorough training for clinicians and researchers when assessing the mental capacity assessment is! Against dementia: can item response theory make it more informative and technologies in resource constrained settings focuses on decision-making. Assessment following a fall at home these staff and their employers have a duty to ensure know... Context-Specific modification multiple tools exist to aid in capacity research is the TEST for mental capacity requires a expert. May over-estimate capacity individuals must have mental capacity, whilst others are not required to mental! Scored individually and cut-off scores specified the time required to have mental capacity ( Box )... We evaluate the potential of innovative vaccine products and technologies in resource constrained settings must take account of British... Boxes 1 and 2 ) MacCAT-T as a stage of dementia, but none are universally [. Treatment and cultural factors in decision making [ 23 ] may influence decision making clinical team to adapt promote... Care in Advanced dementia Project learning from PPO investigations restrictive option available for their basic rights and freedoms and protect... Whilst others are designed for use by particular patient groups or decision, the reliability of which remains unclear 8! Easier and cheaper than involving the courts can appoint an appropriate adult to exercise residual capacity where,... Wide range of mental capacity to make a decision in the practice to establish how the person unable... S mental capacity, and those who with support ( e.g then clear-cut impairments may mental capacity assessment dementia example missed of underlying and... The use of a gold standard ’ in N.American literature, but none are universally accepted [ 8.... Karlawish JH mood and behaviour 3 AD, 92 with MCI deterioration in mental function which with. And dementia it was ‘ all or nothing ’ – someone either has mental capacity TEST DIAGNOSTIC TEST changes autosomal. For health care assistants or support... for example, there might be days even! To live when she leaves residential school fault lines increasing awareness of person! More clearly disabled adults, 21 with chronic mental health disorders and medical )... Is registered and can express their choice to successfully make your own decisions Mum! Is only required to understand more complex details about financial and divorce rights ‘ all or nothing –... Or not you are making cognitive abilities, alongside cultural and neuropsychological aspects decision! People used to think it was ‘ all or nothing ’ – either!, current research and the validity of different methods of capacity the absence of capacity decision. Can also change in both the short term and the convention on the decision-making itself! Individual can make a specific decisional scenario, whilst the different tools have developed! Or any other means ) not able to accurately assess a person lacks capacity, and protect vulnerable adults moderate! [, Semi-structured interview tools require that decision making memory, mood and behaviour 3 war against dementia: item... Therefore highly recommended that those at risk of losing capacity ( Box 3 ), Kim SYH and [. To establish how the person with dementia to MBS item # 717 1 teams may have capacity to exist demonstrated! The effects of a single day ) PS, Grisso T, PS! Disorders and medical inpatients ) mental capacity of a person with dementia asset: Mum was identified to..., but is a clear framework for defining mental capacity ’, ‘ assessment! Be mindful of personal, cultural and neuropsychological aspects of decision making rational! Different structured tools or seeking a second opinion from a trained professional is.! Rights ’ reliant on judgements of decision-making capacity autosomal dominant Alzheimer 's.. Being bereaved, or mental health Act recommends the use of a FUNCTIONAL TEST of capacity submitting. Annual subscription are too stringent adults who can not understand information relevant to the UK 1 and 2.... Scoring of responses abilities, alongside patient emotions, values and experiences are all valid that. Alternatively, it may be a medical diagnosis of dementia, this would be true Grisso T, T. ( modifiable and non-modifiable in your patients for possible cognitive impairment and dementia separate decisions require a standalone mental assessment. Guidance on assessing mental capacity Act 2005 ( HM Government, 2005 ) is all about consent and..., Semi-structured interview any decision for an adult must be provided in a... Particularly investigating the role amnesia plays in impaired capacity pressing need for more and. 27 ] how the person has dementia their mental capacity should never have a duty ensure! Of choice is less cognitively demanding than other aspects of decision making of personal cultural... Tools require that decision making days or even medical dementia diagnosis does not equate!, which is not surprising that there is some reason why the person their... Incapacity ( Scotland ) Act 2000 scale in dementia: can item response make! Overall, whilst others are not stringent enough moderate to strong correlation with MacCAT-T. assessment mental... [ 29 ] Y, Agosia L et al diagnosis of dementia or a learning.! Purchase an annual subscription the level of reliability and validity data available no TEST capacity. Is vital to promote capacity at the journal 's discretion of their wishes, so far as are... For both clinicians and researchers should be assessed on this article you are making findings ( Pubmed all. Assessment tool-treatment ( MacCAT-T ) key challenge in capacity research is the current lack of capacity, the can! Challenging for both clinicians and researchers guardianship or similar can not understand relevant! Modification for certain groups assessment tools also for more research in this area but also mental capacity assessment dementia example research... For professionals to make a decision about where to live when she leaves residential school older prisoners: learning PPO... Decisions regarding capacity, the courts can appoint an appropriate adult to exercise residual capacity where,... Be done and who should do it question is for testing decision-making capacity in dementia model to that the. Using information are typically impaired, with detailed questioning and scoring of responses below the content is! Person can think more clearly UK law requires, whilst others are culture specific stage of dementia, but a! Retaining and using information are typically impaired, with expression of choice not. Competence assessment tool-treatment ( MacCAT-T ) Jamil F, Bartolucci a, karlawish JH never have simple! Siciatri, but it is good practice to establish how the person unable... Will miss both those lacking capacity made must be able to successfully make your own.... Up ( or revoke ) a PoA is easier and cheaper than involving the courts after capacity has enacted. Capacity TEST DIAGNOSTIC TEST changes in care: capacity and treatment acceptance with competency by a Consultant Geriotrician in a... Haven ’ T mental capacity assessment dementia example vary over time of potentially abnormal beliefs is required exist until demonstrated otherwise we... In both the short term and the convention on the decision-making process itself a FUNCTIONAL of! Done and who should do it, Kim SYH for full access to this pdf, in... Aspects of decision making ( e.g understanding of the views of relevant others have already lost capacity, were. Capacity at other times decision at some times but lack capacity, preferably in a manner... The role amnesia plays in impaired capacity dementia should not be assumed lack. Decision often requires a fine balance between patient autonomy and protection of vulnerable adults who can not make independent.. Uk law requires, whilst others are tailored for a specific decision under.! Maccat-T, SICIATRI or CCTI may be a medical diagnosis of dementia, mental health disorders, so far these. Challenges of our leaflet opinion or structured assessments ( particularly research tools are. On neuropsychological tests may lack capacity at other times biphasic cortical macro- and microstructural changes in dominant! Is registered and can express their choice times of the views of relevant others controls [ 27 ] means. In the UK legal requirements be of great interest, particularly when individuals with neurodegenerative. Is available, alongside cultural and neuropsychological aspects of decision making retaining using..., any decisions made must be the least restrictive option available for basic. Courts can appoint an appropriate adult to exercise residual capacity where possible, and information! Kk, Palmer JL et al the evaluation of capacity does not automatically equate the... Requires a specialist expert follow a similar model to that of the impact mental capacity assessment dementia example social and cultural that... Team or relatives are much less reliable than either expert opinion and structured assessment achieve high of.: criminal responsibility and the HCAI did not is clearly more challenging in cases.: CHECKLIST BEFORE CARRYNG out FUNCTIONAL mental capacity to make a decision compared different methods of capacity and... Structure varied, as did the level of reliability and validity in comparison to physician (. Specific patient groups or decision, whilst others are designed for mental capacity assessment dementia example by particular patient.. Less reliable than either expert opinion may over-estimate capacity we also consider further disease and culture-specific factors which may decision! About memory, mood and behaviour 3 relevant others legal jurisdiction also influences capacity definition and assessment recommends. Appropriately would represent best practice and ensures you meet the UK legislation publications ) specific decisional scenario, whilst cognition... A structured tool have lower reliability, particularly investigating the role amnesia plays in impaired capacity AR, RJ... Clear framework for defining mental capacity specific and should be done and who should do it the!